Freedom without love is just an expression of power. I do this, because I can. I am superior, my values are superior... it's a kind of freedom that makes us unequal. Freedom without love is false freedom. Religion without love is just an structure of power. I am superior, my values are superior... it's a kind of religion that makes us unequal.
Selfishly I find
Scottish referendum debate is a thing of beauty, a thing of this day.
But of course, I'm just an observer, I don't have to make such
decision myself. Every layer of it brings all sorts of modern age
topics and questions. No matter what's the result tomorrow, the
exercise of deciding whether they want to stay as a part of the UK or
declare Independence has already changed many things.
For a
country-that-never-had-a-revolution, this is a quite close version of
it. Civilised, of course, it's British. The velvet revolution, they call it. Civilised, even if -after the vote- some steam
might need to get out.
From the political
point of view, allowing a “yes/no” vote has been a big bet. But
it is indeed effective in splitting waters. When we need to make a
decision like this, we are forced to set a hierarchy to values that
we did not know had a hierarchy. The sharp edge of the ballot paper
will separate Scotland from its past. If they decide to stay or to
leave, it will be their active decision of today. It
will be no longer be the past defining their future. It will be their
votes.
The first point about
claiming power back is that it comes with responsibility. Which is
great. There won't be a greater power to blame.
The second is accepting
the discomfort it will generate. Firstly, it will have to reconcile
itself with the winning decision, and in this case around 50% of the
people will be disappointed. Making a decision confront us with a new
knowledge of ourselves at the point that we may not recognise
ourselves. Did we really had the opportunity and did not take it? Did
we really leave the UK?
Their own tolerance,
self-respect and self-love will be put to the test the day after.
Whatever the result, it
is a great attempt to re-democratise politics, which lately has been
too monotone, more concerned about engineering consensus around an
already established agenda than taking countries -and their people-
forward. It has reignited a spark (even in Gordon Brown). Any union that “counts” with a
member to be silent or weak or who is taken for granted, does not
work.
However, “leaving the
clan” to start your own hero journey can be exciting, but does not
guarantee it will be easy. Beyond the separation bureaucracy,
becoming a small dog in the pack will be indeed different. A full
hero's journey awaits and it will be full of dragons, ogres and
trials.
Whatever Scotland
decides, I wish them the very best.
So
far I discussed that fear is within all of us in our
animal core. That fear is primary related to the fear of death and
that the primary way to overcome it is using vertical
power, quick and effective, but generally built over our
first (infantile) coping strategies, that become rigid and are
repeated and replicated even when proven unsuccessful. Again, in
moments of real threat, quick responses are always better than slow
ones.
However
living in fear and under vertical power is like going in first gear
with the car. It does not take you where you need to go. It becomes highly
costly, ineffective, frustrating. It is unable to process quick
enough the small and big decisions needed to deal with a more complex
world, to move quicker or reach further. This happens at every level
of life, from individuals to nations. We have seen many times how, in
moments of crisis, moments of great fear, people expect a vertical
use of power, but the current world is proof of how complex things
are.
Of
course, people that want to profit from this situation will try to
sustain and create the feeling of crisis to justify and accumulate
more power, as this is the way people are kept in infantile state
and are willing to give up power upwards, vertically. However, anyone trying to impose itself with vertical power will also consume itself both morally and economically, because of the force and aggression it needs.
In
absence of fear, or better said, when trust or faith exists, power
needs to be organised in circles. As in this way, power is
shared, collective
intelligence emerge and
more decisions (or bigger ones) are made. However, it also requires a
lot of "fuel", as people need to engage in good
quality conversations (rich, empathic, whilst disciplined) that enable
action instead of blocking it.
So
the evolution from fear to a trusting state of mind, able to
collaborate, is something that we all should aim for as a society.
Then
I discussed that power
is asymmetry. Asymmetry
between sides, forces. Without asymmetry there is no creation, no decision making, no
action.
But
asymmetry creates unbalances, compromises, and for this reason no
action is ever perfect. With time, it will seek to restore the
equilibrium lost by moving to the other side, which will be also unbalanced. So the bigger the
unbalance created, the bigger the change needed, the more radical the
revolution.
There
will always be one of these forces in front of the others but the
others exists and needs to be active in its role. Then, it should be
allowed to emerge to lead and resolve the tensions that the unbalance
naturally creates. As much as walking if the forces are highly polarised: we will only be able to move
forward if the unbalance created in making one step is followed by
the other foot moving forward. If the situation is multipolar, then the movement would be a spin.
If
we understand masculine forces as everything related to structure,
logic, reasoning, deadlines, limits, then the world, and
particularly the west has been dominated by the (wounded) masculine
principle. Almost the entire west world uses the same
alphabet that is highly concrete, almost mathematical. It has been
conceived in the Judeo-Christian tradition - which is a masculine
oriented religion-. Masculine, because it uses a harsh deadline (you
have only one life), and you will be judged at the end. Its
hierarchy has deleted the female presence (father, mother and son)
and made it invisible and passive (a ghost). It has relegated the
"mother" attitudes of protecting and welcoming
behind rule making and judging.
The
west culture more widely has also suppressed emotion or
devalued as something lower than reason. Competition between empires
or between enterprises has been the main economical thought (even if
there is a positive -albeit relative- evolution to move from empires
to nations). Writing rules and either policing or leaving people
"free" to sort it out for themselves has been the main
government style. Of course, the big
assumption here
is that these people are not wounded and are able to self-govern with
ethics (which should naturally include respecting and actively
listening to the other side). However, this is not the case. I've read
(and discussed in my previous entry) that the wounded masculine could
be described as the popular Darth Vader: the powerful warrior that
hides, under his de-humanisedmask, his wounded soul.
Under
a wounded masculine paradigm, states (by their nature, female
entities) are inefficient, somehow lower than the private sector (by
their nature, masculine). The
role of the state must be kept to a minimum and make it as small as
possible (particularly by the right and the liberals, a political
thought that was born out of an occupied country).
An extreme
capitalism would be like living in a house with an immature and
narcissistic father that leaves no space to the mother to act.
However,
we are going through times when we see this put into question. We see
corporations not paying taxes, journalism crossing the borders of
ethics and we question the role of the state again.
We
also see meta-governments being created, distancing power from
people, confusing harmonious collaboration and commercial openness
with the denial of national power. And we think about the role of the
state again.
We
see the environment being savaged and people trying to put a price on
it, and we wonder about the role of the state again.
At
least we have evolved from emperors and fascism, indicating a slow
evolution from fear to trust and collaboration. However the
integration between the female and male principles is still work in
progress. The lack of the feminine creates problems of
inequality, development, collaboration, empathy, mercy and a
disconnection with nature. The lack of integration between the female
and male also creates problems of identity.
On
the other side, an immature, narcissistic, invasive
mother is
offered by communism. Where the whole (and the state) is more
important than the individual. Here the father, in her role of
separating the children from the mother is not allowed to act. The
lack of the masculine creates problems of de-inviduation,
national narratives without critic, people not acting by their own
moral compass and not taking and accepting own responsibilities. A
wounded feminine will also have issues in connecting
with nature.
With
this argument, I mean to say that none of both principles -masculine
or feminine- is right or wrong per se. The extremes are
worst because of the greater unbalance they create, and the violence
they require to impose and sustain themselves. Beyond the extreme
situations, both forces are needed, female and male. Tension is good
as it forces movement and improvements.
Progress
is about keeping these forces working together and aiming to
integrate them. Not through submission or fusion, but in a true partnership and active dialogue. As
much as art integrates science and emotion. A great artist
is highly skilled in technique (science) and is able to connect to
something deeper. In this integration is where real creativity and
life comes from. There is no economical model, no political science.
There is only art. The art of being able to recognise who am I and where I want to go, and then decide on when, how and with
whom. The art of knowing when to be guided by the feminine or male
principle, behave as a mother or a father, or simply let go.
Combining knowledge with instinct.
There
is no science, only art.
AB
Other links:
See
Spiegel's article about Germany's position in Occident: Part
of the West?
Power
is asymmetry. Power is asymmetry. It
is the resolution of a tension that exists between sides
originally equal. Power is the triumphal action of the winning side
to precipitate and materialise potentiality. Making a decision and
taking it to action means that one idea, one intention, took power
over other or others. Even if the winning idea has integrated part of its opposite, there is always a winning idea. Shall I make the pragmatic decision or shall I decide
out of principle? Without this asymmetry we would not be able to eat
as we would not be able to decide anything. Symmetry
neutralises, asymmetry creates.
For that reason, power (and the perceivable physical world) is by its own nature
unbalanced. In this natural order of power, hierarchy is an intrinsic
characteristic of power and therefore inevitable (even though it doesn't have to be static). We
would never be able to create (organize ideas, make a decision and
take an action) without some sort of hierarchies. See The hierarchy of values.
In
economy, in politics, asymmetry is a very well known principle of
power management. If a company would split the shares in two equal
parts, the likelihood is that the decision making will be inefficient
or non-existent.
At
an individual level, how we use our power will dictate (or be
dictated by) our personality. Vertical versus circular power
When
we are connected to fear and we are in front of a perceived threat
(real or imaginary), power will be structured vertically (in our brains and socially) as it will generate quicker responses, albeit less intelligent and
innovative as it tends to replicate known formulas of coping (it triggers instinctive survival behaviour governed mainly by what's called the reptilian brain).
See Identity and crisis.
The
more vertical the power, the less dissent it will allow, the more
aggression and violence it'll require to sustain it. In this dynamic, there is no recognition of the other's individuality, which is only seen
as a resource. This is easier to see at social level or in interpersonal relationships
but it happens first within us. We fragment our personality and give
power to certain characters -normally the ones that were in charge
when we felt fear early on in our lives- and we remove power from what
we consider our weaker sides, our wounded self. In an article of The Guardian, they included some anecdotes of encounters of US politicians with Vladimir Putin: "When George W Bush looked into Putin’s eyes at a Moscow summit in May 2002, he reported, “I was able to get a sense of his soul”. When Joe Biden visited the Kremlin in 2011, he had a very different impression, telling Putin: “Mr Prime Minister, I’m looking into your eyes, and I don’t think you have a soul.” According to Biden, Putin smiled and replied, “We understand each other.” Seeing "souls" is -of course- about seeing beyond the mask that wants to hide our vulnerability. In his reply, Putin outwitted Biden suggesting he wouldn't find any vulnerability in him. Darth Vader is a clear example of "the tragic hero" wounded by the separation from the feminine (his anger develops
from the early separation from his mother, her death and the pregnancy of
his wife), and this wounded side -the son, the husband- gets hidden
under a mask. The warrior took charge but only to obey a ruthless Emperor. This character only
survives with aggression. Once he got in contact again with his son,
with love, he kills the emperor outside and within and ends up removing his mask (literally).
There is an irony in the impatience of the West to impose its democratic ideas. There is also anxiety. In fact, some people in the US argue that power is depleting, it's eroding (See: the end of power). In federal politics, this is partly because elected governments show due obedience to the contributors of the campaigns more than the electorate. Campaigns burn dollars in advertising so they need a lot and "one person, one vote" slowly changed to "one dollar, one vote". But this due obedience is a choice, a self preserving choice. In World politics, it is simply too expensive to impose your will to the entire world. In this regard, power is slowly shifting mechanism from vertical (concentrated, single-minded, highly hierarchical, quicker BUT less sophisticated) to circular (more agents in the table, micro-tensions, asymmetry created by micro-alliances, might be slower if not disciplined, generally smarter). In this shift, that includes the US being more part of a circle, the creative result of power, how it precipitates and materialises, will be much greater (albeit maybe slower). More things will be done.
But this is a process: a process of individuation of people that adds up ("trickle up") to a social and international power rearrangement. Power
of an individuated person, the one that has become adult by successfully separating himself from the (m)other, will associate in
circles. The problems are: 1. no one can do this process for us 2. we cannot do this process for others 3. We are not all at the same stage of this process, ever. Once we recognised ourselves, then we are able to recognise others and are able to successfully organize circular
power,
more creative as it unlocks
collective intelligence. Circular
power not only requires trusting individuals but also the ability to
read, recognise and connect with others whilst have the discipline to
conduct conversations and transactions that enable action.
During the dictatorship in Argentina, people were not allowed to gather in public spaces. The mothers of the people that started to go missing did not have any place to go, to denounce, to complain. They started to gather in Plaza de Mayo and under police orders of "circulate", they started walking in circles, in silence every Thursday. They walked around the pyramid. This circular power was one of great defiance against the vertical power of the dictatorship.
When this process does not truly come from an inner transformation ie someone else killing the "external" Emperor, it does not "work" in terms of enabling people to organise in circles (eg a democratic system), at least not immediately. It was their job to recognise in the external emperor the internal one and gather the force to overcome this brutal father figure -outside and inside-. When the process is cut, we'll probably run amok trying to build a new emperor to kill or we'll go through a period of deep crisis. If this is constantly interrupted, it can become a chronic issue. This is a current topic of discussion that analyses the result of West intervention in the middle east: how much it failed in imposing democracy, can you accept or work with dictatorships?, how much can you really do to bring about stability and social order?, etc. (See The truth about evil, Are dictators worse than anarchy?, Anarchy vs Stability: Dictatorship and chaos go hand in hand). The blurred lines of a circle: still democratic?
However the difference between what is truly a circular and vertical structure sometimes is subtle and not easy to distinguish. The European Union and even more the United Kingdom are in serious debate about it, with the Scottish Independence referendum and even the EU referendum promised by David Cameron. More broadly democracy (circular power) is being discussed more than ever. Is it really circular including us all? or are these circles responding to a vertical structure taking power away from people, like the Lord of the Rings's rings circles ended up responding to a single unchallengeable ring (ie, the 1%, the "market")? In this sense, it's always interesting to see "the market" not approving a democratic result, such as Dilma Rousseff reelection in Brazil.
In vertical structures there is always a surrendering of power. In fact, every time we feel identified with anything there is a transfer of power. Whose
wish is it? Whose wish is it? is
in my opinion the key question to think about when any sort of union is taking
an action (a couple, a family, a group, a country). When it is the wish of one made true by the strength (the libido) of
all then, there is domination. In this case the leading force in the
union becomes a 'devouring mother': the one that feeds from the
libido she steals from the children, depriving them of expressing
their own identity. The one that wishes for you, the one that thinks for you, the one that does for you. Many fairy tales are based around this conflict,
normally through the figure of the witch (representing the bad
mother). I remain truly puzzled by by John F. Kennedy famous speech "My fellow Americans, ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country." It is supposed to be an empowering message but... If we change 'country' for the word 'mother'... then it becomes a slightly creepy 'devouring mother' message and the standing ovation slowly becomes a paused and isolated applause. It does not say "ask what you can do for yourself, for your family" or "whilst we think what this country can do for you, ask what you can do for yourself, your family and your community too" (I admit, though, that it lacks the power of a snappy quote). The distinction can be quite thin. We read it everyday in the news. "Italy is not pushing fast enough for the changes that Angela Merkel wants to see". Whose wish is it?
In economic matters, "this is truly complicated, let us do the thinking for you" is a tacit and constant message which slowly pushes democracy towards the realms of elitocracy. It's refreshing to hear and see Dr. Ha-Joon Chang saying otherwise in his book "Economics, but not as you know it".
But the examples are everywhere. Whose wish is it? is behind our lack of understanding of the Ukraine crisis. How much the Crimea referendum voices the wish of the people living in Crimea? How much it is a civil war and how much it is a covert invasion to stop Nato? But most important of all, because everything starts in a small scale, is "whose wish is it" in our lives? why did I study the career I chose? Was it truly my wish or was I trying to make my parents happy, feed them instead of myself with my choice? (In this article Venus Williams says that tennis was in fact her father's wish) Whose wish is it being expressed with my partner? Do all voices have their space? And with my children?
Dynamic asymmetry Power is by nature unbalanced, I said. But it does not mean that the unbalance needs to be always leaning towards one side (nor that any particular hierarchy needs to be set in stone) on the contrary. The more it is unbalanced towards one side, the bigger the change needed, the bigger the revolution (this word sounds particularly evocative in this context). The quicker we move to regain equilibrium, the further we'll get. As much as walking or probably even better, spinning (it's a circle!)... revolving.
Crisis points would still tend to require a slightly more verticality, though (quicker, more assertive action). I always think of it as I go up a mountain with my car. I could not advance well in fifth gear. I might need to be in 2nd or 3th. But I cannot remain in 2nd gear forever. I would not get where I need to go.